Last Call (Part II): The fans pick the greatest L.A. Dodgers of all time

Assistant Sports Editor

Oct. 31, 2008 11 PM PT

This article was originally on a blog post platform and may be missing photos, graphics or links. See About archive blog posts.

The ballots poured in, 812 of them. For a while, it was neck and neck for No. 1, until one player ran away with it at the end. You were asked to send in your choices for the 12 greatest L.A. Dodgers of all time. The player listed first received 15 points, second place 11, third place 10, all the way to 1 point for being listed in 12th on a ballot. To make the big list below, you had the be listed on at least 25 ballots.

Players listed on fewer than 25 ballots:

Jim Brewer, Brett Butler, Ron Fairly, Al Downing, Shawn Green, Mickey Hatcher, Burt Hooton, Tommy John, Jeff Kent, Paul LoDuca, Mike Marshall (the pitcher), Ramon Martinez, Andy Messersmith, Rick Monday, Ron Perranoski, John Roseboro, Steve Sax, Larry Sherry and Steve Yeager.

Now, in reverse order:

27th place: Manny Mota (46 points)

25th place (tie, 139 points): Claude Osteen, Wally Moon

24th place (209 points): Manny Ramirez

23rd place (255 points): Eric Karros

22nd place (256 points): Jim Gilliam

21st place (278 points): Dusty Baker

20th place (325 points): Wes Parker

19th place (441 points): Mike Scioscia

18th place (512 points): Duke Snider

17th place (534 points): Bill Russell

16th place (580 points): Eric Gagne

15th place (603 points): Pedro Guerrero

14th place (740 points): Kirk Gibson

13th place (742 points): Reggie Smith

12th place (974 points): Willie Davis

11th place (1,578 points): Davey Lopes

10th place (1,670 points): Tommy Davis

9th place (3,202 points): Don Sutton

8th place (3,457 points): Ron Cey

7th place (3,805 points): Fernando Valenzuela

6th place (4,036 points): Orel Hershiser

5th place (4,292 points): Steve Garvey

4th place (5,197 points): Maury Wills

3rd place (5,359 points): Mike Piazza

2nd place (6,844 points): Don Drysdale

1st place (11,716 points): Sandy Koufax. Koufax was the only player listed on every ballot.

Starting next Friday: The greatest L.A. Lakers of all time.

-- Houston Mitchell

Sports Now

Houston Mitchell

Houston Mitchell is an assistant sports editor, writer of the Dodgers Dugout newsletter and editor of all of the sports newsletters for the Los Angeles Times.