‘Why I No Longer Do Abortions’
I am troubled by the misleading opening sentence and the headline of Dr. Flesh’s anguished statement, which imply that he, as an observant Jew, condemns abortion. A careful reading of his piece reveals that Dr. Flesh continues to perform abortions, and to support the legality of abortions-- except second-trimester elective abortions.
In fact, not even the foundational texts of Jewish law absolutely forbid second-trimester abortions. The Mishnah mandates abortion until the actual point of birth when a mother’s life is in danger. Among Jewish legal authorities, there is a range of opinions about what constitutes sufficient cause for ending a pregnancy. As a conscientious Jew, Dr. Flesh has the right to decide whether he places himself with liberal or conservative interpreters of Jewish law. But as a physician serving a secular society, he must be mindful of the crucial boundary between religious norms and secular social policy.
RABBI SUE LEVI ELWELL, Director, Los Angeles Jewish Feminist Center, American Jewish Congress
More to Read
Sign up for Essential California
The most important California stories and recommendations in your inbox every morning.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.