TV REVIEW : ‘Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman’ Is Bad Medicine
The new CBS drama series, “Dr. Quinn, Medicine Woman” is so excruciatingly awful that Jane Seymour should sue the writers for malpractice.
When a bartender orders her out of his saloon because she’s a “lady,” the fetching Michaela Quinn (Seymour), replies, “I’m not a lady, I’m a doctor.”
She’d be just as convincing as a Martian.
In fact, she’s “Dr. Mike,” a high-toned Bostonian who has come west in the post-Civil War era to practice medicine in Colorado Springs, only to be rejected by most of the townspeople because of her gender.
In the marathon two-hour premiere that airs at 8 tonight on Channels 2 and 8, Dr. Mike awkwardly adjusts to rural life while pestering the locals to let her be their doctor. She becomes a surrogate mom to three orphans, and is befriended by Byron Sully (Joe Lando), a hunky loner who hangs out with the Cheyenne and his pet wolf. Meanwhile, “Medicine Woman” dances with wooden characters.
Ever fresh, cool and gorgeous, Seymour looks just . . . marvelous. But when she starts emoting like a frontierswoman (“The only work I knew was doctorin’.”), you know this is monumental miscasting. Nor does it help that Lando’s Sully is a log.
There’s little attempt to give “Medicine Woman” an authentic period look. And with its overcooked depictions of noble Native Americans and ruthless white soldiers, “Medicine Woman” imposes a 1990s social consciousness on the Old West. In Episode 2, a caricaturish Gen. George Custer passes through town in search of Native Americans to abuse. Airing at 8 p.m. Saturday in the series’ regular time slot, this episode finds Dr. Mike courageously fighting a flu epidemic and getting sick herself, with a Cheyenne medicine man riding to the rescue.
More than him, what she needs is a script doctor.
More to Read
The complete guide to home viewing
Get Screen Gab for everything about the TV shows and streaming movies everyone’s talking about.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.