‘Courage Under Fire’ Gives Accurate Reflection of History
In reference to the article by Billie Jean Thompson (“Clearing Up a Question of Valor,” Counterpunch, Aug. 5):
As the screenwriter of “Courage Under Fire,” I am fully aware of Mary Walker’s incredible story and her unique status as the first and only woman to receive the Medal of Honor [which Thompson felt was overlooked in the film]. I know this because I also co-wrote and directed a six-hour television documentary series about the Medal of Honor and many of its recipients.
But Thompson either didn’t see the movie or wasn’t paying attention. The pertinent line in the script is that our fictional heroine is the first woman considered for a Medal of Honor in combat.
While Walker was a thoroughly remarkable individual who deserved far better treatment than she received, her medal was for meritorious service, not combat. A fine distinction, perhaps, but an accurate one.
I agree, Walker was maligned and mistreated in her day--but not by the dedicated people who made “Courage Under Fire” or by 20th Century Fox.
PATRICK S. DUNCAN
Culver City
Only good movies
Get the Indie Focus newsletter, Mark Olsen's weekly guide to the world of cinema.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.
