Judge Calls 3 Nuns ‘Irresponsible,’ Gives Them Prison for Vandalism

Calling them “dangerously irresponsible,” a federal judge sentenced three nuns to at least 2 1/2 years in prison Friday for vandalizing a nuclear missile silo during an antiwar protest last fall.

Despite his strong words, U.S. District Judge Robert Blackburn gave the women less than the six-year minimum called for under sentencing guidelines.

Jackie Hudson was sentenced to 2 1/2 years, Carol Gilbert to 2 years, 9 months, and Ardeth Platte to 3 years, 5 months.

“We’re satisfied,” prosecutor Robert Brown said.

Hudson, 68, Gilbert, 55, and Platte, 66, were convicted in April of obstructing the national defense and damaging government property.

The Roman Catholic nuns cut a fence and walked onto a Minuteman III silo site last October, pounding the silo with hammers and painting a cross on it with their blood.

Officials said that the nuns had caused at least $1,000 in damage.

The nuns had until Aug. 25 to report to prison but chose to go immediately.

Some peace activists have said that the felony convictions were harsh and intended to have a chilling effect on other protesters.

But the prosecutor said that because the nuns were repeat offenders, they deserved to serve time in prison. He said Platte had been arrested at least 10 times at antiwar protests, Hudson five times and Gilbert at least 13 times.

“These ladies could not be deterred for the last 20 years. They will be deterred for the time the court sentences them,” Brown said.

On Friday, the defense asked the judge for leniency, saying even prosecution witnesses agreed the nuns did not harm the national defense.

Beforehand, the nuns defiantly told a crowd of 150 supporters outside the courthouse they were not afraid of prison.

“Whatever sentence I receive today will be joyfully accepted as an offering for peace, and with God’s help it will not injure my spirit,” a choked-up Platte said.

As for vandalizing the silo, Hudson said: “When someone holds a gun to your head or someone else’s head do you not have a right and a duty to enter that arena and stop that crime?”

Many of those outside court waved antiwar banners, including one that read: “No Blood for Oil.”

Platte and Gilbert lived in a Baltimore activist community founded by the late peace activist Philip Berrigan. Hudson lived in a similar community in Poulsbo, Wash.

After their arrest, the three women chose to remain in jail, refusing the government’s offer to release them on their own recognizance.