Hollywood’s crew union negotiations have gone well so far. Now the hard part begins
In a departure from the labor rebellions that roiled Hollywood last year, the latest set of contract negotiations between a major entertainment union and the top studios has unfolded about as smoothly as could be expected. So far.
The various West Coast studio locals that make up the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees, which advocates for film and TV crew members, have engaged over the last month in separate bargaining sessions with the Alliance of Motion Picture and Television Producers, which represents Walt Disney, Netflix, Warner Bros. and other entertainment companies.
Those talks — tailored to the specific concerns of costume designers, hair and makeup artists, set decorators and other workers — transpired without incident.
Now the union representing so-called below-the-line workers was poised to enter broader negotiations Monday for its basic agreement, which will cover the most pressing items affecting entertainment craftspeople. This phase is the big one that could, depending on how talks go, result in another historic agreement or yet another work stoppage.
“The stakes are very high ... certainly in light of what happened last year,” said Todd Holmes, associate professor of cinema and television arts at Cal State Northridge.
“It’s a challenging environment,” he said. “There’s need for cautious optimism because of what’s gone on individually with the crafts, but I still think it’s going to take some time to iron out an agreement.”
IATSE and Teamsters, two unions representing Hollywood crew members, are entering contract negotiations with the studios after the writers’ and actors’ strikes.
Unlike the Screen Actors Guild-American Federation of Television and Radio Artists and the Writers Guild of America, IATSE has never staged a nationwide strike in its 131-year history. It came close, however, in 2021 when crew members overwhelmingly voted in favor of authorizing a walkout. (IATSE and the AMPTP ultimately averted a work stoppage by settling their standoff shortly before the strike was set to commence.)
This year, a crew member walkout is looking increasingly unlikely. However, some have speculated that the slow return to production in the wake of the writers’ and actors’ labor actions could be partly the result of the companies playing it extra safe in anticipation of another potential shutdown.
The overlapping writers’ and actors’ walkouts came as a devastating blow on both sides of the bargaining table, rendering countless crew members jobless for at least six months and upending the release schedules of the entertainment companies, which were already struggling financially because of overspending from the streaming wars.
“Look, people need to work,” said Matthew Loeb, IATSE’s international president. “And to the extent that our goals are met, the earlier [a deal is struck] the better. ... We don’t want companies holding off on greenlighting pictures or moving them. We want to keep the business on track and make the recovery from last year.”
In a statement provided to The Times, a spokesperson for the studios said, “The AMPTP is pleased by the progress we have made and remains focused on the task at hand: collaborating with our union partners to reach a fair deal that keeps crew members on the job without interruption and recognizes the contributions they make to our industry.”
Crew members are expressing frustration at the length of the writers’ and actors’ strikes as Hollywood workers struggle to pay for rent, food and healthcare.
Before the start of broader negotiations, the 13 Hollywood locals struck tentative deals with the AMPTP according to each group’s needs.
The trade-specific agreements fell like dominoes, beginning March 22 with the cinematographers (Local 600), art directors (Local 800) and set painters (Local 729) and ending last week with the studio teachers (Local 884) and affiliated property craftspeople (Local 44). The union has remained tight-lipped about the contents of those deals, though craft-specific contracts historically have addressed issues such as workflow for editors, camera operating practices and working conditions for costumers.
Loeb hopes that’s a good omen for the tenor of the ongoing negotiations.
“It’s civil,” Loeb said. “I think their demeanor is right. Everybody wants to avoid a strike. But that’s not to say that it’s a foregone conclusion that they’ll meet our demands.
“It’s not a war. We don’t bargain for a strike. We bargain for a contract.”
Workers in film and TV, most of whom are pro-union, have been trying to make ends meet amid a dual strike of Hollywood actors and writers.
This wave of bargaining is expected to cover topics such as wages, pension and health benefits, work-life balance and job security, as well as streaming residuals and artificial intelligence, which emerged as sticking points during the writers’ and actors’ contract campaigns.
The efficiency of the craft-specific talks bodes well for the broader negotiations, Holmes observed. He noted, however, that the parties’ “reconciliatory tone” could “go south or ... change quickly” over hot-button issues such as AI.
Members of the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees authorized their leaders to call a strike if they can’t work out a deal with the major studios.
Terms related to pay, subcontracting, work-life balance and AI could prove especially challenging to nail down in the broader negotiations — which will introduce “more difficult issues,” according to a source close to the studios who was not authorized to comment.
In a Monday memo to IATSE members, business representatives for the 13 locals described the broader stage as “the bigger challenge ahead,” citing “more complex and consequential” agenda items.
IATSE is seeking “significant” wage increases to keep up with inflation, higher penalties for rest-period violations, enhanced sick leave and bumps in streaming residuals, as well as regulations around subcontracting and AI. Crew members also are demanding additional funding for their pension and health plans amounting to at least $670 million.
The union has said it doesn’t intend to prolong regular talks beyond the current contract’s expiration date of July 31.
By then, “My hope is that we will have an agreement to send out for ratification,” Loeb said. “But if we don’t, then ... it would be a strike authorization vote.”
The deal between the International Alliance of Theatrical Stage Employees and the major studios is a rare display of muscle for the industry’s “below-the-line” production crews.
The first round of general negotiations is tentatively scheduled to run from April 29 through May 16. Loeb said that the best-case scenario would deliver a resolution in less than two months.
“Conversations have been productive to date, but it’s going to take a while to work through the issues on the table in general negotiations as they’re very complicated” and can’t be resolved overnight, said a source close to the studios who was not authorized to comment.
In March, IATSE, Teamsters Local 399 and other unions representing more than 66,000 below-the-line workers held a rally in Encino’s Woodley Park to kick off their simultaneous contract campaigns. The event was attended by thousands of industry professionals, including crew members, writers and actors — fresh off the success of their own labor actions.
“The AMPTP, they learned a lesson,” Holmes said. “The WGA and SAG played hardball with them, and they held out longer than [the studios] anticipated. So I think that the AMPTP is in more of a mode of negotiation ... than they were a year ago.”
Inside the business of entertainment
The Wide Shot brings you news, analysis and insights on everything from streaming wars to production — and what it all means for the future.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Los Angeles Times.
