Judge to rule on taped conversation in Bechler murder trial
Deepa Bharath
SANTA ANA -- A Superior Court judge is expected to decide today
whether to allow a key exhibit -- surreptitiously tape-recorded
conversations -- as evidence in the trial of a Newport Beach man accused
of murdering his wife.
Eric Bechler’s defense attorney, John Barnett, argued Monday that the
way authorities recorded the dialogue between the defendant and Tina New,
Bechler’s girlfriend at the time, “destroyed Bechler’s relationship with
his attorney” by interfering with attorney-client privilege.
Prosecutors allege that Bechler, 33, threw his 38-year-old wife, Pegye
Bechler, overboard three years ago during a boating trip off the coast of
Newport Beach. He has pleaded not guilty, saying his wife was swept
underwater by a giant wave as she drove a speedboat and towed him on a
boogie board.
Police arrested Bechler in November, three days after Orange County
Sheriff’s Department investigators wired New with a recording device
around her neck, which she used while she and Bechler were eating at a
restaurant.
The tapes, now sealed by the judge, reportedly contain Bechler
describing the circumstances of his wife’s death and revealing that his
marriage had been on rocky ground.
Barnett said Monday that authorities, during the investigation, “went
beyond simply listening to a suspect giving a statement.” He asked that
the court bar the tapes from being entered into evidence because
Bechler’s recorded comments were solicited improperly.
He said New asked Bechler specifically what his attorney told him and
discussed tactics with him. Barnett submitted that New’s “constant
badgering destroyed Bechler’s relationship with John Yzurdiaga, who was
his attorney at the time.”
Deputy Dist. Atty. James Mulgrew said New did not initiate any of the
discussions regarding Bechler’s lawyer.
“The defendant himself brought up the subject of his attorney,” he
said.
Barnett requested Monday that the judge either dismiss the case or
keep the tapes out of the trial.
“This is about the police trying to dig and dig and make a homicide
case where there is none,” Barnett said.
Jury selection is expected to begin this week.
All the latest on Orange County from Orange County.
Get our free TimesOC newsletter.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Daily Pilot.