New method of appointment makes sense
To the winners go the spoils.
That old saying is looking to be truer than ever in Costa Mesa
City Hall now that council members have given themselves the power to
appoint directly their own planning and parks commissioners. Maybe
even more importantly, council members will be able to “fire” their
commissioners if it pleases them.
Opponents, concerned about cronyism and “latch-key” commissioners,
were quick to cry foul last week when the council made the dramatic
change.
“It’s not a bad idea per se, but the implementation and
implications are pretty scary,” said Planning Commissioner Bill
Perkins, who has a stake in just how those appointment are made. “It
causes a lot of hard feelings and makes it very political.”
But that’s exactly what City Hall is -- a political place.
Imagine the president of the United States getting elected and
then having to confer about who the vice president, the chief of
staff or the press secretary will be. Or, even more ludicrous,
imagine the president having to confer before asking someone to
leave.
That isn’t how it works (aside from the back-room politicking, of
course). When voters pick a president, they are picking a leader,
plus all the people that leader appoints. Why should we not expect
the same from our local politicians? We should, for a commission full
of reasons.
First off, the change to direct appointment will solve a nagging
problem in Costa Mesa: disagreement between the Planning Commission
and the City Council. Lately, too much time has been taken up with
re-hearings and overturning votes. Having planners and council
members on the same page will eliminate this -- and if it doesn’t,
then a simple firing will do the job.
The change also will hold council members -- and indirectly,
voters -- more accountable. If a council members’ appointee is doing
a terrible job, it will be easy to point the finger at the right
place. Political heat can be put to council members to make changes
happen. Cronyism, in other words, works in residents’ favor by
bringing the deals out from the back rooms. We’ll know who’s with
whom.
Residents will also have more responsibility when going to the
voting booth. Their votes will not just be for a council member, but
for like-minded commissioners; these “teams” will have increased
power to reshape the political landscape inside City Hall. Three
like-minded council members and their three planning commissioners
will be able to get a lot done during their time in office. As much
as every vote counts now, they will count that much more.
Those worried that too much will get done should feel especially
responsible for the shape of the council and commissions. If you are
concerned about who a council member might bring into City Hall,
think twice about your support. If you don’t like how appointments
have been made, you’ll know whom to call or whom not to vote for next
time around.
It will, after all, be directly apparent to us all.
All the latest on Orange County from Orange County.
Get our free TimesOC newsletter.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Daily Pilot.