Haidl defense wants D.A. off the case
Marisa O’Neil
Defense attorneys for 19-year-old Greg Haidl, whom a judge sent to
jail Tuesday to await retrial on gang-rape charges, filed a series of
motions Thursday, including one asking the district attorney’s office
to recuse itself from the case.
Haidl, son of former Orange County Assistant Sheriff Don Haidl,
along with Kyle Nachreiner and Keith Spann are accused of gang-raping
and sexually assaulting a 16-year-old girl in 2002.
Greg Haidl was booked in county jail Tuesday, after a judge ruled
he had violated the terms of his bail, which required him to steer
clear of drugs and alcohol.
Defense attorneys filed a motion Thursday alleging that Orange
County Dist. Atty. Tony Rackauckas and prosecutors have singled out
Haidl and are out for blood.
Defense attorney Joseph Cavallo alleges that Rackauckas acted
unfairly when he held a press conference, with a large photograph of
Haidl, and called him a “danger to the community.” That press
conference came after he allegedly had sex with another 16-year-old
girl while free on bail.
Cavallo also refers to the placement of Chief Assistant Dist.
Atty. Chuck Middleton on the retrial as a sign that the office is
desperate to prosecute.
“It took their second in command to try this case because they
couldn’t convict the first time,” Cavallo said. “You would think they
could use him on something more serious than this.”
It’s the second time Greg Haidl’s attorneys have asked prosecutors
to recuse themselves since he was arrested in 2002 on suspicion that
he, Nachreiner and Spann raped and sexually assaulted an allegedly
unconscious 16-year-old girl in Don Haidl’s Corona del Mar home. The
three boys videotaped the incident.
Judge Francisco Briseno declared a mistrial in June after a jury
hopelessly deadlocked. Since then, Greg Haidl has had a series of
run-ins with the law, prompting the judge to revoke his bail.
Nachreiner and Spann have stayed out of trouble since the first
trial started.
Charges have been simplified this time around, narrowing them from
24 to nine, to cut down on juror confusion, Middleton said. Middleton
volunteered to work as lead prosecutor because he’s dealt with the
media on other high-profile cases, he said.
The defense’s motions also ask for a deposition by Jane Doe, now
18, to be unsealed and for the prosecution to disclose any jury
records.
“Prosecutors hired a jury consultant,” Cavallo said. “That’s a
waste of county funds.”
Jury selection has not yet started, but Middleton confirmed that
they had hired a consultant, as they do on some large cases.
“We’re concerned about what potential juror might not be fair,”
Middleton said. “We’re not holding mock trials.”
After the judge revoked his bail this week, defense attorneys
fought to keep Greg Haidl, whom they said had attempted suicide
twice, in a hospital to be treated for depression. They argued that
his father’s former position and his emotional state would compromise
his safety, but Briseno sent him to Orange County Jail on Tuesday
while he awaits retrial.
The second trial is scheduled to start Jan. 31.
Cavallo said he visited Greg Haidl in jail Wednesday, and he
seemed to be doing well.
“I slept last night,” Cavallo said after seeing him. “When I left
him, I felt comfortable that he was safe.”
All the latest on Orange County from Orange County.
Get our free TimesOC newsletter.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Daily Pilot.