Iseman answers critics
Councilwoman Toni Iseman was notified June 22 that she would not be
reappointed to the California Coastal Commission, a position she had
held for more than two years.
Iseman was one of the state Senate’s four appointees, two of whom
must be elected officials. Iseman’s seat was filled by Manhattan
Beach City Councilman Jim Aldinger, who will serve as the
commission’s South Coast representative.
Iseman’s replacement came on the heels of sharp criticism from
leaders of the Sierra Club and the Surfrider Foundation, who declined
to endorse her reappointment, questioning her commitment to the
environment, based on their “report card” of commissioners’ votes.
Following is a Q&A; with Iseman and Coastline Pilot reporter
Barbara Diamond.
Q. Were you disappointed in not being reappointed to the
California Coastal Commission?
A. What happened to me is a problem on a personal level -- I loved
being on the commission -- but it goes beyond me.
It is also problem on the county level, because we [Orange County]
no longer have a representative on the commission, and on the state
level.
Taking me off the commission isn’t about me. It’s about the
remaining 11 commissioners who know that [Sierra Club spokesman] Mark
Masara- -- I call him Mark Messiah -- is sitting there with his red
pencil.
By not reappointing me, the rest of the commission was put on
notice.
Q. Are lobbyists like Masara a bad thing?
A. The greatest value the lobbyists have is to bring clients
around to the realization of what it takes to be successful.
Masara goes to commission meetings with his laptop like the 13th
commissioner, and he writes “Coast Watch.”
The commission has about 1,500 votes a year, and his grading sheet
reported less than 35 votes.
Q. What do you think turned the leadership of the Surfrider
Foundation and the Sierra Club against you?
A. If it were not for the Dana Headlands and Bolsa Chica, I would
still be on the commission.
Q. Does the Commission serve a mission?
A. The hours are amazing. If anyone thinks the council meetings
are long -- the commission met at Stanford from 9 a.m. to 9.30 p.m
with a break for lunch and worked through dinner.
Coastal commissioners are so dedicated. You couldn’t get that kind
of work without realizing it is a mission.
Q. What did you see as your obligation as a commissioner?
A. I had an obligation to served the citizens of California and
enforce the California Coast Act.
The essence is protecting water quality, the health of the beaches
and bluffs, the flora and fauna, coastal access and historical and
cultural elements.
Mike Reilly was the chair for two years that I was on the
commission and in conversations he said we have to follow the Coastal
Act.
I said, ‘It’s like the constitution and we are the Supremes
[court].’
Q. Why, then, did Rick Wilson [of Surfrider Foundation] claim that
you ignored the act in your vote on a Pacific Grove project?
A. If the act were that easy to interpret, we wouldn’t need 12
commissioners. It is presumptuous to say the act was violated.
I weighed carefully every vote I made, and I was often on the
short end of the stick. At times, I disagreed with the coastal lobby,
and at other times, I was their only vote.
Q. You were criticized for several votes, including the Dana Point
Headlands. What was your rationale?
A. Dana Headlands was a case of disagreeing with the Surfriders on
whether there was an old seawall or a new one.
Because the Headlands was in my territory, the perception was that
I had a lot to do with getting it through. I was only one vote.
Q. Are there any votes you regret?
A. I would not change a single vote.
Q. What vote are you most proud of?
A. The Headlands is the finest project I saw while on the
commission.
QUESTION
Does Orange County need a representative on the California Coastal
Commission? Write us at P.O. Box 248, Laguna Beach, CA, 92652, e-mail
us at coastlinepilot@
latimes.com or fax us at 494-8979. Please give your name and tell
us your home address and phone number for verification purposes only.
All the latest on Orange County from Orange County.
Get our free TimesOC newsletter.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Daily Pilot.