Officials dispute landslide remarks
Barbara Diamond
City officials reacted Wednesday to a published interview with a
Coastal Commission geologist who was quoted as saying that the
Flamingo Drive landslide was predictable.
The interview with geologist Mark Johnsson was published the day
he was to make a report on the landslide to the Coastal Commission,
which was meeting in San Diego.
“I think it was irresponsible of the commission to release a
report before discussing it with the city’s geologist and city
staff,” Mayor Elizabeth Pearson-Schneider said.
Johnsson said he was misquoted in the news reports.
“I was very careful not to use the word ‘predictable,’” Johnsson
said Thursday. “Predictable implies a short-term time frame.”
In subsequent interviews, Johnsson said he drew the analogy that
an 8.0 earthquake on the San Andreas Fault is predictable, but the
actual timing is not.
“I feel apologetic about the tone of the AP [Associated Press]
story,” Johnsson said. “I just reviewed the work of others who are
doing the hard work.”
Johnsson said he wouldn’t even call his oral presentation to the
commission a report.
“I visited the site, but I did not do any testing,” Johnsson said.
“I just made observations, although a trained geologist can tell a
lot just by looking.”
Johnsson said he is a technical advisor to the commission and he
volunteered to make the presentation. He has made presentations on
other events, including the La Conchita slide.
Johnsson said he talked with the city’s geotechnical consultant
Hannes Richter before making the presentation.
“I confirmed that he and I have pretty much the same conclusions,”
Johnsson said.
Johnsson said he emphasized at the presentation to the commission
that “predictable” was not the right word.
City Manager Ken Frank was not pleased that Johnsson spoke about
his conclusions regarding the landslide.
“I don’t think it was appropriate for a geologist to give an
interview before giving his presentation or without talking to us,”
Frank said. “It was embarrassing for us.”
City Councilwoman Toni Iseman, who served on the coastal
commission until May, said the absence of a commissioner familiar
with local conditions is a problem. Orange County is not represented
on the commission.
“Anyone who thinks it is not important to have a knowledgeable
representative from your area on the commission is just downright
naive,” Iseman said.
The June 1 landslide destroyed or severely damaged at least 21
homes on a south-facing slope in Bluebird Canyon.
A public update on the slide will be presented at 3:30 p.m.
Tuesday in City Council chamber, 505 Forest Ave.
All the latest on Orange County from Orange County.
Get our free TimesOC newsletter.
You may occasionally receive promotional content from the Daily Pilot.