Fair and green proposal

Much has been said over the past years about the Banning Ranch

property and how best to use the land at Newport’s western edge. It

seems the usual suspects are players again, with developers wanting

to build and environmentalists and slow-growth people wanting to

protect open spaces. Is there common ground?

Perhaps there is.

Consider a proposal that allows for some development, maintains

views, provides multiple uses and still protects open space. It is an

idea that addresses each of the common concerns expressed, as well as

developing something novel.

It would be a project we could all be proud of, one that provides

an example for other communities.

There has been some discussion of a small hotel off West Coast

Highway in West Newport. This type of development would have a

relatively low effect on traffic but would bring an increase in

visibility to West Newport. The adage that a rising tide raises all

boats applies here.

This hotel would be the support for the other big part of the

project: an 18-hole championship golf course.

But not just any course, a replica of St. Andrews in Scotland.

Why St. Andrews? Were you aware that this classic course is closed

every Sunday? On Sunday, this wonderful site becomes a community park

open to all.

Families picnic, people walk their dogs and children play ball.

This symbol of golf history serves the local residents in many ways,

not by excluding them but by including them.

This whole concept is so strange to consider; after all, golf

courses here are sacred grounds.

The course would be designed using the same grass from tee to

greens. Nothing would be done to the surrounding roughs. They would

be left natural. This translates to a relatively low cost in

landscape maintenance and water use. This approach makes for some

interesting golf, yet people travel from all over the world to play

these less-than-perfect fairways. Imagine how this St. Andrews of

Newport Beach might become a magnet for aspiring golfers and so many

others that would enjoy playing a true links course without having to

take a trip to Europe.

Newport St. Andrews might become an attraction in itself. What

would that do to the value of West Newport?

St. Andrews of Newport Beach would also act as a sort of balance,

with Pelican Hill’s two courses at the other end.

Here are other reasons and opportunities to explore:

* Bike and walking trails could be woven throughout, connecting to

the other coastal parks.

* There would be no trees that might affect views and require an

increase in water consumption.

* It is a day use park.

* The city of Newport Beach Parks and Recreation Department could

operate this facility and schedule Sunday events as well as classes

and youth programs centered around this style of golf.

* And keep in mind, this facility would have a minimal effect on

the environment, the neighborhood and traffic.

St. Andrews of Newport Beach would maintain open space yet

actually provide an active use area.

There are many ideas being expressed as to the future of this

land, but perhaps none have intrigued the imagination as much as this

one.

If this has piqued your interest, contact your City Council member

and express your views.

DAVE SUTHERLAND

Newport Beach