THAT’S DEBATABLE:

Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger recently said he was prepared to order that about 200,000 state workers have their salary slashed to the federal minimum wage of $6.55 an hour until a new budget is adopted. Union officials have threatened to sue, and State Controller John Chiang has vowed to defy the order, which could cause more lawsuits. Do you think the governor’s potential ultimatum was a productive way to settle the budget stalemate?

The governor’s order was inevitable, given that California government spending has increased an unsustainable 40% since the recall in 2003. California is running out of money. The governor’s order simply reflects reality.

Clearly the governor has the authority to issue this executive order. Controller Chiang’s refusal to carry it out sets up a constitutional crisis further highlighting why we need budget reform and a spending cap.

Chuck DeVore

Assemblyman

(R-Newport Beach)

While we must leave no stone unturned in thinking creatively to solve the budget crisis, the governor’s minimum wage proposal starts an ugly fight with state workers that could prove more expensive in the long run.

In fact, employees may be able to not only claim back pay but also be awarded triple damages should the governor’s action prove to be illegal. Recent legal opinions state that the proposal could result in a very expensive legal battle — all at the expense of taxpayers.

The only viable option is for my colleagues across the aisle to adopt long-lasting fiscal reform so that our state avoids the endless cycles of budget deficits. We need permanent solutions, not political theatrics.

Tom Harman

Senator

(R-Huntington Beach)

Gov. Schwarzenegger’s plan is a continuation of the worthless schemes to paper over the state’s deficits without having any meaningful impact. While freeing up cash in the short term, it does not reduce state expenditures and bring spending into line with projected revenues.

Schwarzenegger’s time would be better spent if he offered some significant budget cuts. The real issue is the refusal to cut spending despite a deficit near $20 billion. Raising taxes to pay for more government spending is the wrong approach when hardworking families continue to pay more for gas and groceries.

Van Tran

Assemblyman

(R-Costa Mesa)