IN THEORY:

A newspaper advertising supplement containing a DVD critical of radical Muslims has sparked a free-speech argument nationwide. Some papers have rejected the ad, and others that did carry it drew complaints and praise from some readers. The hourlong movie, “Obsession,” features graphic images of terrorism as well as anti-American speeches. Do you think it’s appropriate for newspapers to feature such advertising?

As an American, I respect and uphold free speech. Conversely, I stoutly uphold to the principles of free speech; speech that may cause a breach of peace or instigates violence or hate is adamantly prohibited.

Media outlets must have ethical guidelines. They should not become the means in which hate material is being distributed and supplied. Ads that promote racist propaganda should be rejected and stamped as false advertisements because they can hurt, mislead and even provoke the public.

Made by a hate-filled group of individuals, who are notorious for hating Islam and Muslims, the film is an hourlong feeding tube that supplies anti-Muslim propaganda and fear-mongering.

Aristotle once said, “Anger is always concerned with individuals ... whereas hatred is directed also against classes.” This film is that — it is directed hate against American Muslims and Muslims worldwide.

What does the film serve when it focuses on a small element of a much larger population? It serves nothing but to play on people’s fear toward paranoia. The film is drenched in hate; it is a cheap venue to spread bigotry and fear.

The DVD was made back in 2005, but like a hurricane, it has dumped more than 28 million free copies mainly in the key “swing” battleground election states. Does this not seem divisive?

Imam Sayed Moustafa al-Qazwini

Islamic Educational Center of Orange County

In the past few years I have reviewed many publications and videos circulated by those who wish to discredit Christianity and all other religions.

In almost all cases, they are very slanted propaganda. I encourage honest discourse and in exploring our differences, but promoting hatred and distrust through half-truths is damaging to all humanity.

I have seen many attacks and distortions on my own faith. Jews have been attacked by those who believe that they have designs to take over the world. Christians have been characterized as having views compatible with the Ku Klux Klan.

There is no doubt in my mind that the recent distribution of the DVD “Obsession” in swing states is an attempt to influence the upcoming election, which further detracts from its legitimacy. This divisive and dehumanizing attack is demeaning — most of all to those who prepared and distributed it!

My experiences with Islamic acquaintances and my many travels to the Middle East have been refreshing and uplifting. While I am troubled by some of the activities of extremists who say they represent Islam, I reject any misrepresentation of Islam by linking it with this small minority of its members.

“Obsession” is a cunning work of pure propaganda, full of perversions and lies, promoting animosities and fear. It increases tension, strengthens radicalism and promotes division between people of faith. We cannot allow it to color our perception of Islam.

Tom Thorkelson

Director of Interfaith Relations for Orange County