Russian footholds in Middle East, Africa raise threat to NATO

Russian President Vladimir Putin’s invasion of Ukraine dominates world attention. But under less global scrutiny, Putin is also advancing Russia’s presence in the Middle East and Africa — an expansion military and civilian leaders view as another, if less immediate, threat to security in the West.

Putin’s strategy in the Mideast and Africa has been simple and successful: He seeks out security alliances with autocrats, coup leaders and others who have been spurned or neglected by the U.S. and Europe, either because of their bloody abuses or because of competing Western strategic interests.

In Syria, Russia’s defense minister last month showed off nuclear-capable bombers and hypersonic missiles over the Mediterranean, as part of a security partnership that now has the Kremlin threatening to send Syrian fighters to Ukraine.

In Sudan, a leader of a junta that has seized power has a new economic alliance with the Kremlin, reviving Russia’s dreams of a naval base on the Red Sea.

And Mali is the latest of more than a dozen resource-rich African nations to forge security alliances with Kremlin-allied mercenaries, according to U.S. officials.

“What you’ve seen is a Russia that is much more expeditionary and casting its military power further and wider afield,” retired U.S. Gen. Philip M. Breedlove told the Associated Press, saying this has been especially true in the last five or six years.

“Russia is trying to show itself as a great power, as at the seat in world affairs, as driving international situations,” said Breedlove, who was the top NATO commander from 2013 through 2016 and is now a distinguished chair at the Middle East Institute think tank in Washington.

World & Nation

Russia intensifies assault, warns U.S. weapons sent to Ukraine are ‘legitimate targets’

Russia intensifies its invasion of Ukraine as a top Kremlin diplomat warns the U.S. that weapons it is sending to Ukraine are ‘legitimate targets.’

March 12, 2022

But with Putin’s hands already full battling the fierce resistance from a much weaker Ukrainian military, his expansionist goals in the Middle East and Africa are viewed by experts as a potential long-term threat, not a present danger to Europe or the North Atlantic Treaty Organization.

“It’s threatening NATO from below,” Kristina Kausch, a European security expert at the German Marshall Fund think tank, said of the leverage Russia is gaining. “The Russians have felt encircled by NATO — and now they want to encircle NATO,” she said.

To achieve its strategic aims, Russia provides conventional military or Kremlin-allied mercenaries to protect the regimes of often-outcast leaders. In return, these leaders pay back Russia in several ways: with cash or natural resources, influence in their affairs or staging grounds for Russian fighters.

These alliances help advance Putin’s ambitions of returning Russia’s influence to its old Cold War boundaries.

Russia’s new security partnerships also aid it diplomatically. When the U.N. General Assembly condemned Putin’s Ukraine invasion this month, Syria joined Russia in voting against the resolution, and many of the African governments that have signed security deals with Russian mercenaries abstained.

Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov said Friday that Russia would bring recruits from Syria to fight in Ukraine. The threat was seen primarily as an intimidation tactic, and U.S. officials say there has been no sign of Syrian recruits in Ukraine. Some security experts say Russian mercenaries are using Mali as a staging ground for deployment to Ukraine, but U.S. officials have not confirmed these reports.

Regardless of the imminence of the threat, U.S. and European leaders are paying increasing attention to Putin’s moves in the Middle East and Africa — and Russia’s growing alliance with China — as they formulate plans to protect the West from future aggression.

German Foreign Minister Annalena Baerbock said in mid-February that the West could no longer ignore the competition for influence across Africa, where China spends billions on infrastructure projects to secure mineral rights, and Russia provides security through Kremlin-allied mercenaries.

“We see and realize that if we withdraw from this competition as liberal democracies, then others are going to fill these gaps,” Baerbock said as Western diplomats huddled on the Ukraine crisis in the days before Russia’s invasion.

Perhaps the boldest example of Russia flexing its global reach came last month, when it sent defense minister Sergei Shoigu to Damascus, Syria, to oversee Russia’s largest military drills in the Mediterranean since the Cold War, just as Russia’s military made final preparations for its assault on Ukraine.

The drills, involving 15 warships and about 30 aircraft, appeared choreographed to showcase the Russian military’s capability to threaten the U.S. carrier strike group in the Mediterranean.

Russia’s Hmeimeem air base on Syria’s Mediterranean coast has served as its main outpost for launching attacks in the country since September 2015. Russia’s attacks in Syria, which leveled ancient cities and sent millions of refugees to Europe, allowed President Bashar Assad’s brutal government to reclaim control over most of the country after a devastating civil war.

“Hmeimeem base is now an integral part of Russia’s defense strategy, not just in the Middle East but all the world,” said Ibrahim Hamidi, a Syrian journalist and senior diplomatic editor for Syrian affairs at the London-based Asharq al-Awsat newspaper.

In Africa, too, Russia is open to working with leaders known for anti-democratic actions and abuses of human rights.

On the eve of Russia’s invasion with Ukraine, Kremlin officials met in Moscow with an officer of a military junta that seized power in Sudan.

Isolated by the West, Gen. Mohamed Hamdan Dagalo warmly responded to Russia’s overture of a new economic-focused alliance. Upon returning home, Dagalo announced that Sudan would be open to allowing Russia to build its long-hoped-for naval base at Port Sudan on the Red Sea.

It’s far from certain that Russia would be able to take advantage anytime soon. The Ukraine invasion is straining its military and financial resources and showing Russia’s military weaknesses, and international sanctions are crippling its economy.

But in the long term, a Red Sea port could help give Russia a greater role in the Mediterranean and Black Sea, increase its access in the Suez Canal and other high-traffic shipping lanes and allow it to project force in the Arabian Sea and Indian Ocean.

“They certainly could create enough havoc to cause problems,” said Breedlove, the former NATO commander.

Russia’s expanding alliances aren’t just about its conventional military.

From 2015 to 2021, Russian mercenary security outfits increased their presence around the world seven-fold, with operations in 27 countries as of last year, according to the Center for Strategic and International Studies. The most prominent outfit is the Wagner Group, which the U.S. and EU consider to be a surrogate of the Russian military; the Kremlin denies it even exists.

From Libya to Madagascar, security contracts granted to Wagner Group and others give Russia access to mineral resources, staging grounds for deployments and substantial footholds challenging Western nations’ influence.

The U.S. and Europe expressed alarm in December at reports that the Wagner Group had signed a security contract with the Mali government valued at $10 million a month. Experts say Wagner Group took advantage of local unhappiness over the failures of a years-long French-led deployment in the sub-Saharan region targeting extremist factions.

Mali denied any such deployment, but some in the country saw the arrival of Russians as a slam to the colonial ruler France, which had struggled to protect Mali against armed extremists. They hope for better results from any Russian fighters arriving in the country.

“Long live Russia!” cried one man in a crowd, cheering the sight of a Russian delegation in January in the capital, Bamako. “Long live the people of Mali!”